Investicum - one of the last 2 Hamster Mahicans out there - have talked about these a lot in the past, nothing new to say. Out of all Hamster shenanigans, this one seems to be holding on the best. Unfortunately, the author has managed to blow many accounts in the past trading with this EA, thus, we don't have any positive expectations with this one either. Yes, he communicates with his followers, but most of that is just some jibber-jabber nonsense; on top of that, he recently decreased his deposit size by 4x, loosing confidence, hmm?
Blackwave Pacific - this one is backed by ton of capital, resulting in rather high total score. Despite all that $$$, trading efficiency is sub-par and money management is lacking at times. Realistically, this one should decrease it's aggressiveness 2 or 3 times, in order to qualify higher in terms of money management - this is the only major improvement that can be made here. With regards to trading efficiency, it is what it is - the system has been running for almost 4 years without any meaningful changes, therefore, efficiency is somewhat limited.
MIDNIGHT EXPRESS - yes, it's Eleni, and yes, it's another version of Hamster. The only reason this one got in here -> every trade has it's SL, so there is an actual hope for at-least some money management. It is impossible to tell what's gonna happen with this one, as there are 101 currency pairs being traded simultaneously. Deposit load remains idiotically high, but who cares as long as there are SLs, right? As with all Hamsters, trading efficiency remains considerably above average. Out of all dumbasses out there, this person actually speaks with her subscribers, which lifts the total score even higher. Probably, even too high, but hell - who knows...
Shikari - what can we say here? - signal that focuses on it's strongest qualities and ignores everything else. Trading efficiency is below average, while everything else is much better. Likewise to Blackwave, ton of $$$ behind this one, however, combined with reasonable and sustainable money management. End result? - one of the 4 best signals out there.
Criptotradert - normally, we would avoid analyzing signals that are being run on MT5, however, we are expanding our horizons this month, so - mjeh, let's see. With this signal, we are somewhat torn apart - it has many good sides, but all of them feel... a bit blurry?
Efficiency is definitely there, growth/DD ratios are very solid; there are a ton of different currency pairs being traded, thus, diversification of trades is definitely helping this one. In terms of money management, drawdown feels controlled, but, honestly - impossible to say... Because it's MT5, no SL/TP of positions are displayed; deposit load figures are way too high, and, combined with manual trading element here, we have no clue whether these DD levels are result of pure luck or there is some underlying sense. One could say that history of 3 months is not long enough, however, there are 400 trades made in this period - again, that's quite a lot and should be comforting for any potential investor. The signal's broker is unknown, yet, who cares? - trading history is legit, signal has been up&running on MQL5 since the very beginning.
Unfortunately, there are some obvious problems with this signal that don't allow it to rank any higher. First and foremost - balance; 600$ balance that is copied by a grand total of 121k $, that's just wrong. Unless the author increases his balance 10x and takes some risk on his side as well, this signal won't classify any higher. Secondly, the author has made some dubious statements, like, "the signal aims to reach 35% growth per month" -> well, if that's true, it will end-badly, as 35% level is unsustainable and trying to reach that will sooner or later fuck-up money management. Normally, we wouldn't care about such claims (or these would be less-emphasized), however, trading is purely manual here, thus, we don't know at what moment the author will lose his mind and start acting unreasonably (as seen before with other such signals).
Professor - lots of controversy surrounding this one, however, for us, it still remains one of the very best signals out there. Yes, this last month was pretty much garbage, yet, money management remains exceptional and potential is still there. Although some of existing subscribers are absolutely disgusted with recent trading results (absolute loss of 10%), losses can happen time to time with signals that strictly control their downside, so we are not losing our minds with this. What annoys us about this signal, honestly, is the communication - it's there, but, hell, probably, there are times when it would be better to just keep Your mouth shut and sit in the damn corner.